Our Spirits

Cinder & Smoke – 17 Year – Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Etched in stone above the door since 1930, the word EXCELSIOR greets all those who enter our building. Originally designed to inspire students each day as they entered what was once a school, it now inspires us to produce the best spirits possible. Distilled in Tennessee and well-seasoned in Kentucky, the bourbon in your hand is curated from our oldest stock, the result of intended purpose, extreme patience, and the determination to always reach higher.

ALC/VOL: 51%
PROOF: 102
SIZE: 750ML
PRICE: $399

Mash Grains: Corn, Rye, Malted Barley

Tasting Notes:

“Oak profile is well-integrated and clean, featuring coconut, vanilla, dill, and orange; the palate bursts with orange blossom and fresh herbs, concluding with a long, floral, spiced orange finish.” 
Barleycorn Awards

“Chocolate, vanilla, and graham cracker s’mores! YUM!”
ASCOT Awards


Cinder & Smoke Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

ALC/VOL : 47%

PROOF: 94

SIZE: 750ML

PRICE: $61

Mash Grains: Corn, Rye, Malted Barley

Tasting Notes: “This whiskey is light and effervescent with pops of vanilla and lemon, along with some dark brown sugar and light oak. Clean and bright, it’s a quirky and fun sip.”


Cinder & Smoke OLOROS0
Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Finished In Spanish Oloroso Sherry Casks

ALC/VOL : 50%

PROOF: 100

SIZE: 750ML

PRICE: $88

Mash Grains: Corn, Rye, Malted Barley

Tasting Notes: “A complex nose of toffee, toasting marshmallows, and fruit carries through to the smoky, drying finish.”


Cinder & Smoke FOUNDER’S SELECT – Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Continuing the award-winning heritage of Cinder & Smoke Bourbon, Founder’s Select is a special project that requires special attention. In the course of sampling our mature spirits, sometimes there are barrels that stand out. Our Founders, Thomas and Kim Bard, set these barrels aside, experimenting with different combinations, until they create a unique spirit that holds true to the flavor, feel, and finish that you expect from Cinder & Smoke.

Each very small batch of Cinder & Smoke Founder’s Select consists of only three barrels of mature Kentucky Straight Bourbon. The spirit in each bottle was selected, blended, bottled, labeled, and signed by our founders, a true testament to the care and detail that you expect from a craft bourbon.

ALC/VOL : 50%

PROOF: 100

SIZE: 750ML

PRICE: $100

Mash Grains: Corn, Rye, Malted Barley

Tasting Notes: “Orange rind and vanilla aromas lead to a cinnamon laden sip with a wonderful mouthfeel and length to spare on the long, pleasant finish.” – John Barleycorn Awards


Muhlenberg Silver Mühl Whiskey

ALC/VOL : 62%

PROOF: 124

SIZE: 700ML

PRICE: $27.99

Mash Grains: Corn, Wheat, Malted Barley


Muhlenberg Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey

Distilled, Aged and Bottled on a hill overlooking the little mining town of Graham, this hand crafted spirit has spent a few seasons in the dark, waiting to be hauled out and shared with the world.  A lot of hard work went into the bottle you are holding and we wouldn’t have it any other way.  This is the Spirit of Muhlenberg.

ALC/VOL : 52.5%

PROOF: 105

SIZE: 700ML

PRICE: $37.50

Mash Grains: Corn, Wheat, Malted Barley

Tasting Notes: Surprisingly smooth for such a high proof, new make whiskey. Full flavored and sweet.


Muhlenberg Apple Pie Mühl Whiskey

Voted BEST FLAVORED WHISKEY by Fred Minnick’s ASCOT Awards, MUHLENBERG Apple Pie Mühl Whiskey sets the standard for what an apple pie whiskey should be. We hope you like dessert, because you’re going to taste the whole damn pie.

ALC/VOL : Batches vary between 25% – 27.5%

PROOF: Batches vary between 50 – 55 Proof

SIZE: 700ML

PRICE: $27.99

Mash Grains: Corn, Wheat, Malted Barley

Tasting Notes: Full of flavor from start to finish, with more notes coming forward with each and every sip. Every element of an apple pie is there, from the cooked apples and cinnamon, all the way down to the crust. A great desert whiskey by itself and fantastic in a cocktail.


Muhlenberg Blackberry Mühl Whiskey

A great sipping whiskey with a fruity flare! If you love blackberries, give this spirit a try. This is one of our most popular cocktail whiskeys.

ALC/VOL : 35.5%

PROOF: 71

SIZE: 700ML

PRICE: $27.99

Mash Grains: Corn, Wheat, Malted Barley


Muhlenberg Orange Cream Liqueur

We know what you are thinking!  And yes, it tastes just like your favorite orange cream popsicle!  Creamy orange flavor that truly feels like it just might melt in your mouth.  Our multi-multi-award winning liqueur is our most popular summer product!  But hurry, it is only offered from the first day of summer to the first day of fall. 

ALC/VOL : 15%

PROOF : 30

SIZE: 700ML

PRICE: $27.99


Muhlenberg Salted Caramühl Cream Liqueur

ALC/VOL : 15%

PROOF: 30

SIZE: 700ML

PRICE: $27.99

Mash Grains: Corn, Wheat, Malted Barley


ALC/VOL : 50.5%

PROOF: 101.0 (In honor of John’s birthday, October 10th)

SIZE: 700ML

PRICE: $76

Mash Grains: Corn, Wheat, Malted Barley

Tasting Notes: “This is a soft and spicy crowd pleaser with a nice balance
of savory flavors poking through classic a mix of caramel and toffee. Lovely.”

Limited to 6,000 Bottles WORLDWIDE

We can ship to most states + D.C. EXCEPT: Alabama, Alaska, Hawaii, Idaho, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Utah. We cannot ship outside of the U.S.